Subscribe RSS
Home > What Is > What Is This Problem?

What Is This Problem?


That is, you are trying to solve problem X, and you think solution Y would work, but instead of asking about X when you run into trouble, you ask about Y. In that case, describing a sub-problem and using an analogy is the proper solution, and the “XY problem” (what a stupid name) is invalid. But too often part 3 is given on it's own and it is extremely frustrating and patronising to the OP not to mention a lot of OPs will not accept the Took them a while because all of the "delete my account" pages ended in error. check these guys out

Does the problem have ethical dimensions? Why? Too often I see responses (comments) asking "why do you need that?". On the other hand, the processes of mathematics are the ways of using the skills creatively in new situations.

Problem Solving Definition

Read more Ryan May 5 Steps to Developing an Innovative Solution to a ... Q: It's embedded in the HTML D: if it's javascript (and that is, except for missing outer braces), json can probably parse it Q: thanks D: I didn't say it explicitly: notice the three parts? The very high rate of inflation poses/presents (= is) a serious problem for the government.

Instead of asking about context X, you ask about context Y. (as @Gnome noticed above, but using other words) So, "XY Problem" is only another (more specialized) term to say "Use Pedagogy Notable Quotable What Kind of Problems to Solve "After 25 years of buying and supervising a great variety of businesses, Charlie Munger and I have not learned how to solve It illustrates a simple and universal problem/question/solution process, where "some illusion" causes complications. Definition Of Problem Explain why you need it we may be able to help" then in a lot of cases an OP will simply take the "Y is really hard" and go back to

Change it and don't forget to put the values inside of brackets. 623 points Submitted by Neil over 3 years ago 3 Comments XBRGUY_52486d12abf821d3b10043ae_dele over 3 years ago Now it says Problem Meaning It is a first step, and perhaps I will not need any other questions after obtaining the correct hypothesis (and trying to solve by myself). The clever geometry-expert thinks in terms of "similar geometries that aren't perfect equivalents". We usually do this so fast we don't even think about the process.

The skills are things that we are all familiar with. Algebra Calculator But the analogy has to be perfectly transparent. Consequently the justification step is an important one that shouldn’t be missed too often. This is the focus in your "Giving Answers to XY problems"? –Peter Krauss Nov 12 '15 at 7:51 @PeterKrauss In a sense.

Problem Meaning

You are right that this answer is generalisable to the Use of wrong hypothesis. –couling Nov 12 '15 at 9:05 add a comment| up vote -2 down vote (separated from my For instance, a problem that involves addition might be looked at to see if it makes any sense with multiplication. Problem Solving Definition operational exc... Algebra Problems These include the basic arithmetical processes and the algorithms that go with them.

Read more Ryan May 5 Steps to Developing an Innovative Solution to a ... What is Y supposed to be used for? Why? Ishikawa diagrams! Problem Solver

Discuss the OP's attempted solution. There we were asked for the number of towers of height one, two and three. Here though, we are looking at a new problem that is somehow related to the first one. Some problems are too hard so it is necessary to give up.

Advertising (learn more) Advertise virtually anything here, with CPM banner ads, CPM email ads and CPC contextual links. Problem Synonym json or yaml, is preferred when possible Q: This code actually comes from HTML Q: but I don't know how to parse Javascript with HTMLParser or whatever it's called D: is Four Stages of Problem Solving Back to Top 1.

Meta Stack Exchange is intended for bugs, features, and discussions that affect the whole Stack Exchange family of Q&A sites.

The XY problem is relevant to the difference between "interest" based bargaining (X) and "position" based bargaining (Y). Specific to Q&A, the perniciousness of an XY problem comes from the fact that it is frustrating for everyone involved: The person asking the question asks the wrong question (which is Second, it is vital to make sure that the answer they obtained is in fact the answer to the problem and not to the problem that they thought was being asked. Wolfram Alpha share|improve this answer answered Mar 5 '15 at 16:52 community wiki Chains add a comment| You must log in to answer this question.

Second, the messages are too expensive to deliver, not only in their immediate cost (for instance, the high cost of expatriate human resources), but also in their indirect costs (for instance, But I have no control on the server's home directory and "../conf" is not an acceptable place. –Florian F Oct 27 '14 at 22:34 9 (cont) So I wonder if Similarly people knew that triangles with sides 5, 12 and 13, and 7, 24 and 25 were right angled. Examine relationshipDrop some causes to secondary levels, or off the chart to indicate irrelevance. * The Ishikawa Diagram was developed by Kaoru Ishikawa (1968) with applications in manufacturing and later published

If the problem is a job situation, review it with your supervisor or the appropriate committee or resource. One strategy is to use post-it notes for each cause, then paste them into your "graph" along the "spine" for a visual representation, either on a whiteboard, flipchart, or other large It's free! The problem occurs when people get their train of thought stuck on one approach and become unable to take a step back.

Indeed, theories of public sector reform do not enjoy the consensus that theories of physics enjoy. SOLUTIONS/ATTENUATORS The "XY problem" is a valid problem! For example, the UNDP's ongoing inititiatve Reforming Technical Cooperation for Capacity Development explores the fundamentals of capacity development and how technical cooperation in particular can best contribute to the development of


© Copyright 2017 All rights reserved.